On this page6 sections
After a crash, the treatment you need and the money to pay for it rarely line up. You may have no health insurance, a deductible you cannot cover, or a plan that will not approve the imaging or therapy your doctor recommends. A letter of protection (LOP) is one way injured Texans bridge that gap: the provider treats you now, and your lawyer gives written assurance that the bill will be paid out of any recovery from the person who caused the crash.
The Supreme Court of Texas has described the arrangement in just those terms. In In re K & L Auto Crushers, LLC (2021), the Court explained that personal-injury lawyers sometimes provide letters of protection to their clients’ healthcare providers, in lieu of immediate payment, to assure future payment from the proceeds of any recovery, citing a decision of Houston’s Fourteenth Court of Appeals. The Joseph Law Firm uses LOPs so participating doctors and medical providers can treat clients without upfront payment, with the providers paid from the settlement.
An LOP is useful, but it is not free care. It affects what you may owe, how the defense attacks your medical bills and what is left for you at the end. This guide explains each of those points so you can decide with your lawyer and your doctor whether an LOP fits your situation.
How does a letter of protection work?
An LOP is a private agreement. Your lawyer sends it to a doctor, clinic, imaging center or surgery center, and the provider agrees to defer payment until the case resolves. When the case settles or a judgment is paid, the provider’s bill is paid from the proceeds, along with any liens, before the remaining money goes to you. That is different from a hospital lien, which comes from a statute rather than an agreement.
Three practical points follow. First, the provider decides whether to accept an LOP, and not every provider will. Second, the balance accumulates as treatment continues, so you should know where it stands at every stage. Third, because payment depends on the outcome, providers who treat under LOPs have a stake in the case. The Supreme Court of Texas noted in K & L Auto Crushers that providers treating under letters of protection invested themselves in the outcome and the amount of damages recovered, which is one reason their bills draw scrutiny.
Do you still owe the bill if the case loses or settles low?
That depends on the documents, so read them before treatment starts. An LOP changes when the provider gets paid; it does not by itself erase what you owe. Providers may also ask you to sign their own financial agreement, and those terms can decide what happens if the case produces no recovery or less than the bills.
K & L Auto Crushers shows how much the wording matters. There, the attorney’s letters promised to “attempt” to pay the providers “only for any reasonable and necessary medical charges,” and the Court found nothing in the record legally obligating the patient to pay the full amount charged if that amount was unreasonable. Your paperwork may say something different. Ask, and get the answers in writing:
- Am I personally responsible for any balance if there is no recovery?
- Will you consider reducing the bill if the settlement is limited?
- Will you bill my health insurance or PIP instead, or in addition?
- Could this account be sold or transferred to someone else?
How can a letter of protection affect the value of your claim?
It can make your medical bills larger on paper and easier to attack. Texas limits recovery of medical expenses to the amount actually paid or incurred by or on behalf of the injured person (Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 41.0105). When a health insurer pays, write-offs drop out, and the Supreme Court of Texas held in Haygood v. De Escabedo that recovery is limited to amounts the provider has a legal right to be paid. In K & L Auto Crushers, by contrast, the providers treating under LOPs billed their full “chargemaster” rates.
The defense can then challenge whether those charges are reasonable. The Court held in K & L Auto Crushers that the negotiated rates such providers accept from private insurers and public payors, and their costs, are relevant to whether the full rates billed to the patient were reasonable, and that the trial court abused its discretion by refusing the defendants’ narrowed discovery requests outright. The Court also said that even if a patient were bound to pay an unreasonable amount, the defendant’s liability would still be limited to a reasonable amount.
Proof matters too. Texas lets a provider’s affidavit establish that charges were reasonable and services necessary unless the other side serves a timely counteraffidavit from a qualified person (§ 18.001), and the defendants in K & L Auto Crushers did serve counteraffidavits contesting the bills. None of this means an LOP is a mistake. It means the bills need records showing why each service was needed and why the price was fair.
How is an LOP different from health insurance or a hospital lien?
Each one pays your providers through a different door:
- Health insurance pays providers at rates negotiated with the plan. You pay deductibles and copays, and the plan can seek reimbursement from your recovery, capped for plans covered by Chapter 140 at the lesser of half your gross recovery or the benefits paid.
- A hospital lien arises by statute. If a hospital admits you within 72 hours of the crash, it can claim a lien on your claim for the lesser of 100 days of charges or half of your recovery (Property Code § 55.004).
- An LOP defers payment to the end of the case on terms you, your lawyer and the provider set.
They can be combined. Emergency care might run through health insurance or a hospital lien while later therapy runs on an LOP. Which mix works for you is a medical and legal judgment, and our guide to who pays medical bills after a Texas car accident maps the other payers.
What should you ask before you sign one?
Treat an LOP like any other agreement that affects your recovery. Before signing:
- Get copies of the letter and any provider financial agreement.
- Ask about rates: what the provider will charge, and how that compares with what it accepts from insurers.
- Confirm whether PIP or health insurance will be billed. PIP pays without regard to fault (Insurance Code § 1952.155), so it can cover early bills.
- Ask how reductions work if the recovery is limited.
- Keep treatment medical. Choose care because your doctor recommends it, not because of how it is billed; the defense will ask whether each service was necessary.
- Track every LOP balance so your lawyer can account for it in settlement talks. How long your case may take, covered in our guide to Texas injury case timelines, affects how large those balances grow.
At The Joseph Law Firm, attorney Jim A. Joseph can explain how an LOP would interact with your coverage and liens during a free consultation. Decide only after you understand both the treatment an LOP pays for and the balance it may leave behind.
Common questions
Is a letter of protection the same as a medical lien?
No. A letter of protection is a private agreement in which a provider defers payment until your case resolves. A hospital lien is created by Texas Property Code Chapter 55 and attaches to your claim by law when you were admitted to a hospital within 72 hours of the crash. Both get paid out of a recovery, but the hospital lien has a statutory cap and filing rules, while an LOP's terms come from the documents you, your lawyer and the provider sign.
Can I use a letter of protection if I have health insurance?
You may be able to, but it is a choice with trade-offs. Health insurance usually means lower negotiated rates and a plan that may seek limited reimbursement from your recovery, while an LOP provider may bill full rates that the defense can challenge as unreasonable. Some people use insurance for emergency and primary care and an LOP for treatment their plan will not approve. Work through the numbers with your lawyer first, and tell every provider which arrangement applies.
What happens to a letter of protection if I lose my case?
It depends on what you signed. An LOP moves the payment date to the end of the case, and whether you still owe the provider after a loss or a small settlement turns on the letter and any financial agreement you signed with the provider. Look for language about your personal responsibility if there is no recovery, and ask the provider and your lawyer to put the answer in writing before treatment begins rather than after.
Will the insurance company find out I treated under a letter of protection?
Expect that it will. In a Texas injury suit, initial disclosures include medical records and bills reasonably related to the injuries, and the Supreme Court of Texas has allowed defendants to seek discovery from LOP providers about the negotiated rates they accept from insurers and their costs. The Court said providers treating under letters of protection have a financial stake in the outcome and give up some of the protection disinterested third parties receive.
Does The Joseph Law Firm use letters of protection?
Yes. The firm uses letters of protection so that participating doctors and medical providers can treat clients without upfront payment, with providers paid from the settlement. Whether an LOP makes sense for you depends on your coverage, your treatment plan and the providers involved. Attorney Jim A. Joseph can walk through those questions in a free consultation.
Sources (8)
- In re K & L Auto Crushers, LLC, No. 19-1022 (Tex. 2021)txcourts.gov
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.0105 (medical expenses paid or incurred)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Haygood v. De Escabedo, No. 09-0377 (Tex. 2011)search.txcourts.gov
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 18.001 (affidavits on cost and necessity of services)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 140 (contractual subrogation rights of payors)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Prop. Code ch. 55 (hospital liens)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.155 (PIP payable without regard to fault)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 194.2 (initial disclosures)txcourts.gov
Prepared from public sources by the firm's editorial team. Pending review by attorney Jim A. Joseph. Last updated . This page is general information, not legal advice. Read our editorial policy
The information provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be considered legal advice for your case. Please contact our lawfirm for legal advice about your case.

