Car Accidents5 min read

Should you give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer?

No Texas law requires you to give the other driver's insurance company a recorded statement. The Texas Department of Insurance notes you have no contract with that company, unlike your own insurer. Adjusters often ask quickly, before you know how an injury will turn out, because early answers about speed or fault can be used against you later. You can decline, answer factual questions in writing, or wait until a lawyer reviews your case.

Talk with attorney Jim A. Joseph

Free consultation

Prefer to talk? Call 855-355-LAWS, Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CT.Your case may be referred to the Kwok Daniel, Ltd., LLP, law firm.Privacy policy

On this page6 sections
  1. Do you have to give the other driver’s insurance company a recorded statement?
  2. Why do insurance adjusters want your recorded statement right away?
  3. Is it different when your own insurance company asks for a statement?
  4. What should you rely on instead of a recorded statement?
  5. What should you do if the adjuster calls today?
  6. Common questions

The call often comes within a day or two of a Houston-area crash: a friendly voice from the other driver’s insurance company asking you to answer a few questions “for the file,” sometimes recorded. It feels routine. It is not neutral. The person on the phone works for the company that will later decide how much, if anything, it owes you for your car and your injuries.

Nothing in Texas law requires you to give that company a recorded statement. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) puts the basic relationship plainly: you have no contract with the other driver’s insurer, so you do not have the same options you would have with your own company. That gap matters more than most people realize, because the legal protections built into Texas insurance law mostly run between an insurer and its own policyholder, not between an insurer and the stranger it may end up paying.

Below is what you are and are not required to say, why adjusters often call quickly, how the rules change once it is your own insurer asking, and what to rely on instead of a recorded call.

Do you have to give the other driver’s insurance company a recorded statement?

No. Texas has no statute requiring a crash victim to give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver’s insurer. TDI’s own consumer guidance explains why that is different from dealing with your own company: you have no contract with the other driver’s insurance, so you do not have the same options you would have with your own (TDI: dealing with the other driver’s insurance). A recorded statement helps the company asking for it. It is not a step the law makes you take.

The person collecting that statement works for the side that may end up paying your claim. TDI describes the adjuster’s role simply: the adjuster works for the insurance company paying the claim, and that company bases its decision on what the adjuster reports back (TDI: working with an insurance adjuster). Declining a recorded statement, or offering to answer basic questions in writing instead, does not forfeit your claim or your right to pursue it later.

Why do insurance adjusters want your recorded statement right away?

Speed works in the company’s favor. Early in a claim you may not yet know the extent of an injury that takes days to appear, such as a soft-tissue or head injury, and a recorded description of how you feel can be used later even after your symptoms change. An offhand estimate of your speed, your distance from the other car, or where you were looking in the seconds before impact can also become evidence of your own fault.

Texas juries, not recorded statements, ultimately decide how fault is divided. In a lawsuit, the trier of fact assigns a percentage of responsibility to every person who contributed to the harm, including the claimant, based on the evidence at trial (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.003). Our guide to Texas’s 51 percent bar explains how that percentage affects what you can recover. A recorded answer given before you have seen a crash report or a doctor can still shape that evidence long before any jury hears the case, which is exactly why the other side wants it on record early.

Is it different when your own insurance company asks for a statement?

Yes, in two ways: the relationship and the clock the law puts on the company. Your own policy is a contract, and most Texas auto policies expect you to cooperate with your insurer’s investigation of a claim it owes you directly, such as personal injury protection, medical payments or uninsured motorist coverage. TDI’s consumer guide notes that a company does not owe you the usual 60 days’ notice before declining to renew your policy if you do not cooperate in a liability claim, one sign of how seriously Texas insurers treat that duty (TDI auto insurance guide).

Deadlines back this up. When your own insurer is paying a first-party claim, defined by law as one a policyholder makes against their own company, Texas requires it to acknowledge the claim within 15 days, accept or reject it within 15 business days of getting everything it needs, and pay within 5 business days of agreeing to pay (Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.051, 542.055 to 542.057). None of those deadlines apply when the other driver’s company is deciding your claim. TDI says so directly: the prompt payment law does not apply if another driver’s insurance company is paying the claim, though that company must still act in good faith and try to settle it quickly and fairly (TDI auto insurance guide). The Insurance Code’s unfair settlement practices section mostly protects a company’s own policyholder, too; it does not give a third party like you a direct claim against the other driver’s insurer for violating it (Tex. Ins. Code § 541.060(b)).

What should you rely on instead of a recorded statement?

Documents that do not depend on memory or wording under pressure. A certified crash report, often called the CR-3, records the responding officer’s independent account of the scene; our guide on getting a Texas crash report covers how to request one. Photographs of the vehicles, the road and any visible damage, plus the names and numbers of witnesses, do the same job as a recorded statement without the downside of locking you into an early guess.

Medical records carry more weight than a description of pain given over the phone before you have been examined. If your own medical bills are the immediate concern, our guide on who pays medical bills after a car accident in Texas walks through PIP, health insurance and other sources. And if the crash involved a city, county or state vehicle rather than another driver, the rules and deadlines change again; see our guide on crashes with a government vehicle in Texas.

What should you do if the adjuster calls today?

You can talk without being recorded. Give basic, factual information: your name, the date, time and location of the crash, and the fact that police responded. Decline the recording plainly: “I’m willing to answer basic questions, but I’m not comfortable being recorded right now.” Nothing in Texas law penalizes that answer, and a reasonable adjuster will simply note it and move on.

Avoid guessing about injuries, speed or fault, and read any medical authorization closely before signing one a company other than your own insurer sends you, since a broad release can let it pull records unrelated to the crash. You have time to get this right: a personal injury lawsuit in Texas generally must be filed within two years of the crash (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003), so a day or two to gather the crash report and see a doctor before answering the adjuster’s questions rarely costs you anything. For a free consultation about a Houston-area crash, attorney Jim A. Joseph can review what the other insurer has asked for before you respond.

Common questions

Do I have to give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver's insurance company?

No. Texas has no law that requires a crash victim to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer. The Texas Department of Insurance explains that you have no contract with that company, so you do not have the same options you would have with your own insurer. You can decline a recording and still offer the basic facts: the date, time, location and that a police report was taken. Declining does not forfeit your right to pursue the claim.

What should I say if the adjuster calls before I have seen a doctor?

Stick to facts you are certain of and avoid describing your injuries in detail. Pain from a car crash, especially in the neck, back or head, often gets worse over the following days, and a recorded guess made too early can be used later even after your symptoms change. It is reasonable to tell the adjuster you are still being evaluated and will follow up once you have seen a doctor and reviewed the crash report.

Can the other driver's insurer use my statement against me later?

Yes. In a Texas lawsuit, the jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to every person who contributed to the crash, including the claimant, based on the evidence presented at trial. An early, recorded answer about your speed, distance or attention in the moments before the crash can become part of that evidence long before you have seen the crash report or spoken with a lawyer. That is a major reason adjusters ask quickly, and a major reason to slow down before answering.

Is it different when my own insurance company asks for a statement?

Yes, in two ways. Your own policy is a contract, so most Texas auto policies expect your cooperation with your insurer's investigation, including a statement, when it is paying your own claim, such as personal injury protection or uninsured motorist coverage. Texas law also puts real deadlines on your own insurer, requiring it to acknowledge, investigate and decide on claims within set time limits. None of those deadlines bind the other driver's insurance company, which only has to act in good faith.

What if the adjuster says a recorded statement will speed up my payment?

Treat that claim carefully. Texas's prompt payment deadlines for insurance claims apply to your own insurer paying a first-party claim, not to the other driver's company deciding whether to pay you at all. A recorded statement does not put the other insurer on any faster legal clock. If a faster resolution matters to you, ask what specific information would help and consider providing it in writing instead of on a recording.

Should I sign the medical authorization the other driver's insurer sends me?

Read it closely before signing anything from a company that is not your own insurer. A broad authorization can let that company request medical records far beyond those related to the crash. You can offer records tied specifically to this crash and this treatment instead of a blanket release. A personal injury claim in Texas generally must be filed within two years of the crash, so taking a day or two to review paperwork carefully rarely costs you anything.

Sources (8)

  1. Tex. Ins. Code § 541.060 (unfair settlement practices)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  2. Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.051, 542.052 (prompt payment of claims: first-party definition and applicability)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  3. Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.055 to 542.057 (claim acknowledgment, decision and payment deadlines)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  4. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.003 (jury determines percentage of responsibility)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003 (two-year limitations period)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  6. Texas Department of Insurance: Accident not your fault? Here's how to deal with the other driver's insurancetdi.texas.gov
  7. Texas Department of Insurance: Working with an insurance adjustertdi.texas.gov
  8. Texas Department of Insurance: Automobile insurance guidetdi.texas.gov

Prepared from public sources by the firm's editorial team. Pending review by attorney Jim A. Joseph. Last updated . This page is general information, not legal advice. Read our editorial policy

The information provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be considered legal advice for your case. Please contact our lawfirm for legal advice about your case.

Free consultation

Have a question about your own case?

Tell attorney Jim A. Joseph what happened and ask how Texas law may apply to your situation.

Prefer to talk? Call 855-355-LAWS, Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CT.Your case may be referred to the Kwok Daniel, Ltd., LLP, law firm.Privacy policy

  • Free consultation. There is no obligation to hire the firm.
  • You will not pay any legal fees unless we win your case. client will only be responsible for court costs and case expenses if we win.
  • With a letter of protection, participating doctors and medical providers can treat you without upfront payment.
Call 855-355-LAWSFree consultation