Refinery & Plant Accidents4 min read

What happens if a Texas non-subscriber employer's negligence hurts you at work?

In Texas, most private employers may legally skip workers' compensation insurance and become non-subscribers. If a non-subscriber employer's negligence hurt you on the job, you generally sue in civil court instead of filing a comp claim, and Texas law stops the employer from blaming you, a coworker, or your own risk-taking for the injury. The Joseph Law Firm offers a free consultation to review a non-subscriber claim.

Talk with attorney Jim A. Joseph

Free consultation

Prefer to talk? Call 855-355-LAWS, Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CT.Your case may be referred to the Kwok Daniel, Ltd., LLP, law firm.Privacy policy

On this page6 sections
  1. How do you know if your Texas employer is a non-subscriber?
  2. How is suing a non-subscriber different from filing a comp claim?
  3. What waivers and exceptions can still limit your claim?
  4. What evidence and deadlines matter in a non-subscriber claim?
  5. What should you do next after a non-subscriber workplace injury?
  6. Common questions

Texas is one of only a few states that lets most private employers decide for themselves whether to carry workers’ compensation insurance. An employer that opts out is called a non-subscriber, and a meaningful share of Texas employers make that choice every year. If a non-subscriber’s negligence hurt you on the job, you are not filing a workers’ comp claim. You are bringing an ordinary negligence lawsuit against your employer in state court, and Texas law changes several rules in your favor to make up for the fact that no comp benefits are waiting on the other side.

That trade-off cuts both ways. You give up the no-fault comp system, where you get paid medical and income benefits regardless of who caused the accident. In exchange, if you can prove your employer was negligent, a jury can award the full range of ordinary damages, and the employer loses some of its best courtroom defenses. Below: how to tell whether your employer is a non-subscriber, what changes once you sue, the waivers and exceptions that can complicate a case, the evidence and deadlines that matter, and what to do next.

How do you know if your Texas employer is a non-subscriber?

Texas makes workers’ compensation coverage elective for most private employers rather than mandatory (Tex. Lab. Code § 406.002). An employer that skips coverage must notify the Texas Division of Workers’ Compensation in writing between February 1 and April 30 each year, and again after hiring its first employee or dropping a policy (§ 406.004). It must also post a notice of no coverage in English and Spanish and give new hires written notice of its status (§ 406.005). In the Texas Department of Insurance’s last published snapshot, about 75% of private Texas employers carried coverage in 2022, which means roughly one in four did not (TDI, 2022 non-subscriber estimates). If you are unsure about your own employer, TDI staff will confirm its coverage status by email, usually within one business day (TDI coverage verification).

How is suing a non-subscriber different from filing a comp claim?

You must prove the employer, or someone acting within the scope of their job for the employer, was negligent (§ 406.033(d)). In exchange, the employer loses three defenses it would otherwise have: it cannot blame your own contributory negligence, cannot argue you assumed the risk, and cannot point to a coworker’s negligence instead of its own (§ 406.033(a)). The Texas Supreme Court has described a non-subscriber’s duty as a nondelegable obligation to use ordinary care in furnishing a safe workplace and safe equipment, a duty the employer cannot shrink by blaming the injured worker’s own share of fault the way an ordinary defendant could (Austin v. Kroger Texas, L.P., No. 14-0216 (Tex. 2015)). Because there is no comp-style cap, a successful suit can reach the full range of Texas personal injury damages: medical costs, lost earning capacity, and physical and mental pain, covered in our guide to what damages Texas law allows.

What waivers and exceptions can still limit your claim?

The employer keeps two narrow defenses: that you intended your own injury, or that you were intoxicated at the time (§ 406.033(c)). A waiver of your right to sue signed before you were hurt is void (§ 406.033(e)), but a waiver signed afterward can be valid if it is voluntary, comes no earlier than the 10th business day after you first reported the injury, follows a medical evaluation from a nonemergency doctor, and is written conspicuously (§ 406.033(f), (g)). Some larger non-subscribers instead enroll workers in a private injury-benefit plan with an arbitration clause at the time of hiring, and the Texas Supreme Court has held that doing so does not itself violate the ban on pre-injury waivers and can bind even a worker’s surviving family to arbitrate (In re Golden Peanut Co., No. 09-0122 (Tex. 2009)). Read anything your employer asks you to sign after an injury closely, and have it reviewed before you sign.

What evidence and deadlines matter in a non-subscriber claim?

Because this is a civil lawsuit rather than a comp claim, the usual comp paperwork deadlines do not apply to you. Instead, the ordinary two-year personal injury limitations period controls, running from the date you were hurt (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003; see our statute of limitations guide for exceptions that can move that date). Evidence that matters includes the employer’s safety and maintenance records, training files, any internal incident report, and coworker witness statements. If the employer has five or more employees and you missed more than one day of work, it was required to report your injury to the Division of Workers’ Compensation within one month and seven days (TDI non-subscriber reporting rule); whether it actually did is worth asking about. If your injury happened at a refinery or chemical plant, our guide to OSHA and CSB records after a refinery explosion covers the additional federal paper trail those sites generate.

What should you do next after a non-subscriber workplace injury?

Get medical care, write down what happened while the details are fresh, and either ask the employer directly or email TDI’s coverage desk to confirm its subscriber status on the date you were hurt. Keep a copy of anything HR asks you to sign before you sign it, and do not assume a friendly conversation with a supervisor protects your rights the way a written record does. Because you have two years and must prove negligence to recover anything, gathering the right records early matters more in a non-subscriber case than it does inside the comp system.

The Joseph Law Firm offers a free consultation to go over a non-subscriber workplace injury and what an employer’s own safety records might show. Certain cases may be taken on a contingency basis, where you pay no attorney fees unless you win; client will only be responsible for court costs and case expenses if we win.

Common questions

Does every private employer in Texas have to carry workers' compensation insurance?

No. Texas lets most private employers decide for themselves whether to carry workers' compensation insurance, and an employer that opts out is called a non-subscriber under Tex. Lab. Code § 406.002. A non-subscriber still has to notify the state and its own employees that it carries no coverage. By the state's last published count, about one in four private Texas employers had chosen not to subscribe. Public employers and a few other categories are treated differently, so confirm your specific employer's status rather than assuming.

Can a non-subscriber employer still argue that I caused my own injury?

Only in limited ways. Texas law strips the employer of three common defenses: it cannot blame your contributory negligence, argue you assumed the risk, or point to a coworker's mistake instead of its own negligence. The employer can still defend by showing you intended to injure yourself or were intoxicated at the time of the accident. Outside those two narrow defenses, you need to prove the employer, or someone acting for it, was negligent, not that the employer caused everything that went wrong that day.

What compensation is available if you sue a non-subscriber employer and win?

A successful negligence suit against a non-subscriber is not capped the way a workers' compensation claim is. Depending on the evidence, it can include your medical expenses, lost wages and reduced future earning capacity, and compensation for physical pain and mental anguish, the same categories available in other Texas personal injury cases. There is no guaranteed outcome and no set figure. A jury decides the amount after hearing evidence about what the employer did wrong and how seriously you were hurt.

How long do I have to sue a non-subscriber employer in Texas?

Generally two years from the date you were injured, the same personal injury deadline that applies to most Texas negligence claims. That clock is separate from, and usually longer than, the short notice and filing deadlines inside the workers' compensation system, because a non-subscriber claim is an ordinary lawsuit, not a comp claim. Certain circumstances can pause or change the deadline, including the age of the injured worker, so do not guess at your own date without confirming it.

What if my employer asks me to sign something after my injury?

Read it closely before you sign anything. A waiver of your right to sue signed before an injury happens is void under Texas law, but one signed afterward can be enforceable if it is voluntary, follows a medical evaluation, comes at least ten business days after you reported the injury, and is written conspicuously. Some employers instead use arbitration agreements tied to a private injury-benefit plan offered when you were hired, which Texas courts have allowed. Either document can decide whether your case goes to a jury, so have it reviewed first.

I work for a staffing agency or subcontractor at a non-subscriber worksite. Does this apply to me?

It depends on who counts as your employer for workers' compensation purposes, which is not always the company running the job site. Your staffing agency's or subcontractor's own subscriber status controls whether you have comp benefits or a non-subscriber negligence claim against that specific employer. A separate property owner or general contractor at the same site can face its own, different liability, which our guide on contractor injuries at refineries and plants covers in more depth.

Sources (10)

  1. Tex. Lab. Code § 406.002 (coverage generally elective)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  2. Tex. Lab. Code § 406.004 (employer notice to division)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  3. Tex. Lab. Code § 406.005 (employer notice to employees)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  4. Tex. Lab. Code § 406.033 (common-law defenses; burden of proof)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003 (two-year limitations)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
  6. Texas Department of Insurance: Non-subscriberstdi.texas.gov
  7. Texas Department of Insurance: Workers' compensation coverage verificationtdi.texas.gov
  8. Texas Department of Insurance: Texas workers' compensation non-subscriber estimates, 2022 (published April 2023)tdi.texas.gov
  9. Austin v. Kroger Texas, L.P., No. 14-0216 (Tex. 2015)search.txcourts.gov
  10. In re Golden Peanut Co., No. 09-0122 (Tex. 2009)search.txcourts.gov

Prepared from public sources by the firm's editorial team. Pending review by attorney Jim A. Joseph. Last updated . This page is general information, not legal advice. Read our editorial policy

The information provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be considered legal advice for your case. Please contact our lawfirm for legal advice about your case.

Free consultation

Have a question about your own case?

Tell attorney Jim A. Joseph what happened and ask how Texas law may apply to your situation.

Prefer to talk? Call 855-355-LAWS, Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CT.Your case may be referred to the Kwok Daniel, Ltd., LLP, law firm.Privacy policy

  • Free consultation. There is no obligation to hire the firm.
  • You will not pay any legal fees unless we win your case. client will only be responsible for court costs and case expenses if we win.
  • With a letter of protection, participating doctors and medical providers can treat you without upfront payment.
Call 855-355-LAWSFree consultation