On this page6 sections
People call it the black box, but a modern tractor-trailer can hold several separate data sources, each with its own rules. The engine control module, or ECM, is a manufacturer-installed computer that can store information about speed, braking and engine activity. The electronic logging device, or ELD, is the federally required recorder of a driver’s duty status and hours. Many fleets also run messaging and telematics systems, and some trucks carry cameras.
Together, these sources can answer the questions that decide truck cases: how fast the truck was moving, whether and when the driver braked, where the truck had been, how long the driver had been on duty and what dispatch was telling him. None of that data is certain to survive. The truck stays in the carrier’s hands, federal retention periods for logs are measured in months, and engine data is not on the federal retention list at all.
The practical answer is a fast, specific written demand and, when that is not enough, a court order. This guide explains what each source records, how long it lasts, when Texas law imposes a duty to preserve it and how a download is usually handled.
What data can a commercial truck record?
It depends on the system, and the ELD is the most standardized. Federal rules require an ELD to record the date, time, location, engine hours, vehicle miles and driver, vehicle and carrier identification whenever the driver changes duty status, when the engine powers up or shuts down, and at least once an hour while the truck is moving (49 C.F.R. § 395.26). During authorized personal use, location is logged only to roughly a 10-mile radius. FMCSA describes the ELD as synchronized with the engine to record driving time automatically (FMCSA).
Engine module data is far less uniform. The federal event data recorder rule applies to passenger cars, trucks and buses with a gross vehicle weight rating of 8,500 pounds or less (49 C.F.R. § 563.3), so a heavy truck’s ECM is not built to that standard, and what it stores varies with the manufacturer, the engine and its settings. Only an examination of the particular unit shows what it captured.
Fleet messaging is a third source. Electronic communications sent through a fleet management system count as supporting documents that carriers must keep with the logs (§ 395.11), and they can reveal dispatch instructions, delays and the driver’s own reports in the hours before the crash. If the truck carried a camera system, ask for that footage too.
How long will the trucking company keep the data?
Only as long as the rules require, unless someone asks for more. These are the main federal minimums:
| Record | Federal minimum retention |
|---|---|
| Records of duty status (ELD logs) and supporting documents | 6 months |
| Driver vehicle inspection reports | 3 months |
| Inspection, repair and maintenance records | 1 year, and 6 months after the vehicle leaves the carrier’s control |
| Accident register, with copies of required accident reports | 3 years |
| Driver qualification file | Length of employment plus 3 years |
Those periods come from § 395.8, § 396.11, § 396.3, § 390.15 and § 391.51. Engine module data appears nowhere on the list, so its survival depends on the equipment and on what the carrier does next, including whether the truck is repaired, sold or put back on the road.
Post-crash drug and alcohol testing runs on an even shorter clock. When a federal post-accident test is required, an alcohol test not given within 8 hours and a drug test not given within 32 hours is abandoned, leaving only the carrier’s written explanation (§ 382.303).
When does Texas law require the company to preserve evidence?
A party’s duty to preserve evidence arises when it knows or reasonably should know that there is a substantial chance a claim will be filed and that evidence in its possession or control will be material and relevant to that claim, as the Texas Supreme Court confirmed in Brookshire Brothers v. Aldridge (Tex. 2014). A serious injury crash involving a commercial truck may meet that test on its own, but a written demand removes any argument that the company did not see a claim coming.
When evidence is lost after the duty arises, the trial judge decides whether spoliation occurred and picks a proportionate remedy. The harshest remedy, an instruction letting the jury presume the missing evidence would have hurt the party that lost it, generally requires a finding that the party acted with the specific intent to conceal discoverable evidence. Negligent loss supports that instruction only in the rare case where the other side is irreparably deprived of any meaningful ability to present its claim.
Federal rules add their own prohibitions. No carrier or driver may destroy or alter a supporting document, and no one may tamper with an ELD so that it fails to record and retain accurate data.
Who can download the data, and what does Texas law say about access?
Texas restricts access to information from a manufacturer-installed recording device, which the statute defines to include features that record speed and direction, location, steering or brake performance, or seat belt status, or that transmit crash information. That information may not be retrieved by anyone other than the vehicle’s owner except on court order, with the owner’s consent, for safety research that does not identify the owner or driver, or to facilitate an emergency medical response (Tex. Transp. Code § 547.615).
In practice, an injured person’s team usually needs the owner’s agreement or a court order to download a truck’s engine data, and the owner may be a leasing company rather than the carrier named on the door; our guide to who can be liable for an 18-wheeler accident explains those relationships. One sensible way to handle it is a joint inspection, with technicians for both sides present and everyone receiving the same copy of the download, which heads off later disputes about who handled the data.
ELD records stand on a different footing. They are business records the carrier must keep and make available to federal and state enforcement officials investigating an accident (§ 390.15), and in a lawsuit they are requested through discovery. Our guide to hours-of-service rules explains what those logs can prove.
What should a preservation letter ask for?
A preservation letter should be specific, go out within days, and reach every company that may hold evidence. Send it to the motor carrier whose name and USDOT number appear on the tractor (49 C.F.R. § 390.21T), to the owners of the tractor and trailer if they are different companies, and to their insurers. Ask them to keep:
- the tractor and trailer, unrepaired, until both sides can inspect them;
- engine control module and other event data, with a request for a joint download;
- ELD records and the underlying electronic data for the trip and the days before it;
- supporting documents, including bills of lading, dispatch records, receipts, fleet messages and payroll or settlement records;
- driver vehicle inspection reports and maintenance files;
- the driver qualification file and any post-accident drug and alcohol test records;
- the accident register entry, internal crash reports, photos and camera footage.
Ask the investigating agency for its crash report and photos as well, which our guide on getting a Texas crash report explains. A letter cannot force anyone to comply, so when the truck may be repaired or sold, an attorney can ask a court for an order protecting it. For help sending one, The Joseph Law Firm offers a free consultation with attorney Jim A. Joseph.
Common questions
Is a truck's engine module the same as a car's black box?
Not exactly. The federal event data recorder standard covers passenger cars, light trucks and buses with a gross vehicle weight rating of 8,500 pounds or less, so passenger vehicles equipped with a recorder must capture a common set of data elements. Heavy trucks fall outside that standard, and their engine modules store whatever the manufacturer designed them to keep. That is why the first step with a tractor-trailer is identifying the engine and its software, then having someone qualified retrieve the data before the truck is repaired or returned to service.
Can I get the truck's data without filing a lawsuit?
Sometimes. Texas law lets the vehicle owner, or someone acting with the owner's consent, retrieve data from a manufacturer-installed recording device, so a carrier or leasing company can agree to a joint download before any suit is filed. If the owner refuses, the alternative is a court order, which usually means filing suit or asking a court for pre-suit relief. Either way, the request should be in writing and made quickly, because the truck may be repaired, sold or put back on the road while the parties negotiate.
Will the ELD show how fast the truck was going?
Not directly. The data elements listed in the federal ELD rule are date, time, location, engine hours, vehicle miles and identification information, recorded at duty status changes, engine start and shutdown, and at least hourly while the truck moves. Braking and a moment-by-moment speed trace are not on that list. Average speed between two recordings can sometimes be worked out from time and location, but the engine module and any camera footage are better sources for the final seconds before impact.
What happens if the trucking company loses or deletes the data?
The judge decides whether that was spoliation and what to do about it. Under the Texas Supreme Court's framework, the injured party must show the company had a duty to preserve the evidence and breached it, and the remedy must be proportionate to the company's culpability and the harm caused. The court described remedies ranging from an award of attorney's fees to dismissal, with a jury instruction about the missing evidence reserved mainly for intentional concealment. A clear written preservation demand makes the duty much harder to dispute.
Should I keep my own vehicle and its data after a truck crash?
Yes, if you can. Passenger vehicles built since September 2012 that have event data recorders must capture items such as vehicle speed, service brake use and driver seat belt status, and under Texas law you, as the owner, control who retrieves that data. Your own car's record can help answer claims that you caused the crash. Tell your insurer and any tow yard in writing that you want the vehicle held, and avoid authorizing salvage or repair until your attorney has decided whether the vehicle or its data needs to be inspected.
Sources (10)
- 49 C.F.R. § 395.26 (ELD data automatically recorded), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. § 395.8 (records of duty status, retention and ELD tampering), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. § 395.11 (supporting documents), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. §§ 396.3, 396.11 (maintenance and inspection records), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. § 390.15 (accident register), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. § 382.303 (post-accident testing), eCFRecfr.gov
- 49 C.F.R. § 563.3 (event data recorder rule applicability), eCFRecfr.gov
- FMCSA: Electronic Logging Devicesfmcsa.dot.gov
- Tex. Transp. Code § 547.615 (recording devices)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Brookshire Bros., Ltd. v. Aldridge, 438 S.W.3d 9 (Tex. 2014), No. 10-0846search.txcourts.gov
Prepared from public sources by the firm's editorial team. Pending review by attorney Jim A. Joseph. Last updated . This page is general information, not legal advice. Read our editorial policy
The information provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be considered legal advice for your case. Please contact our lawfirm for legal advice about your case.

