On this page6 sections
- What makes a vehicle “uninsured” or “underinsured” under Texas law?
- Can an insurer refuse to sell UM/UIM coverage, or can you turn it down?
- What has to happen before your own insurer actually pays a UIM claim?
- What if you cannot identify the other driver, or only your car needs fixing?
- Where do you bring a UM/UIM claim, and what should you track?
- Common questions
Texas requires every driver to carry liability insurance, but that requirement does not disappear the moment a driver skips it or buys too little. When the person who hit you has no insurance, or a policy too small for what you are owed, the coverage that usually steps in is your own: uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, shortened to UM/UIM. It rides along on your auto policy, not the other driver’s, and Texas requires insurers to offer it on nearly every policy sold in the state.
UM/UIM is not automatic money the way some drivers expect. Texas treats it as a contract claim against your own insurer that still depends on tort law: you have to show the other driver was at fault and what your damages are worth, and in many cases your insurer owes nothing until that is pinned down by a judgment or an agreement. That timing trips people up more than almost any other part of a Texas injury claim. This guide covers what counts as uninsured or underinsured, how the coverage is offered and rejected, what has to happen before your insurer pays, and where a property-damage or phantom-vehicle claim changes the analysis.
What makes a vehicle “uninsured” or “underinsured” under Texas law?
An uninsured motor vehicle is one with no liability insurance at all, and Texas law also treats a vehicle as uninsured when the insurer that covers it cannot pay because the insurer itself is insolvent (Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.102). An underinsured motor vehicle is different, and often misunderstood: it is a vehicle that does have collectible liability insurance, but the limits on that policy are lower than the UIM limits in your own policy, either because they started lower or because other claims from the same crash already used some of them up (§ 1952.103).
That comparison point matters. The test is not simply whether your medical bills are bigger than the other driver’s policy; it is whether that driver’s liability limits are lower than the UM/UIM limits you bought. If you carry higher UM/UIM limits than the state floor, more drivers will count as underinsured to you than they would to a neighbor who kept the bare 30/60/25 limits described in our minimum insurance guide.
Can an insurer refuse to sell UM/UIM coverage, or can you turn it down?
An insurer cannot leave UM/UIM off a Texas auto policy on its own. Every company that sells auto liability coverage in this state must include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, in limits tied to the state minimum, unless a named insured rejects it in writing (§ 1952.101). You can generally buy UM/UIM bodily injury limits up to the same amount as your own liability limits, and UM/UIM property damage coverage up to your own property damage limits, subject to a $250 deductible on the property side (§ 1952.105).
A written rejection carries forward. If you turned the coverage down on an earlier policy with the same insurer or an affiliated one, the insurer does not have to offer it again on a renewal or reinstated policy unless you ask for it in writing. Check your declarations page rather than assume; many Houston-area drivers carry UM/UIM without remembering they ever agreed to it, and others are surprised to learn they once turned it down.
What has to happen before your own insurer actually pays a UIM claim?
Usually a judgment, or an agreement with your own insurer, establishing both the other driver’s fault and that the vehicle was underinsured. The Texas Supreme Court addressed this directly in Brainard v. Trinity Universal Ins. Co., 216 S.W.3d 809 (Tex. 2006), holding that a UIM insurer has no contractual duty to pay until the insured obtains a judgment establishing the other motorist’s negligence and underinsured status, and that neither a demand letter nor filing suit against the insurer, by itself, creates that duty.
You do not have to sue the at-fault driver to get there. The court noted that an insured may settle with the at-fault driver first with UIM insurer permission and then pursue the UIM insurer separately, often by suing that insurer directly and letting a jury decide, within that lawsuit, what the at-fault driver’s negligence and your damages would have been. What a settlement with the at-fault driver cannot do on its own is prove you are owed UIM money, since a jury could still find no fault or award less than that driver’s own policy already covered. Because the timing is unusual, get an attorney involved before you sign a release with the at-fault driver’s insurer; a release written for that claim can affect your UIM claim too.
What if you cannot identify the other driver, or only your car needs fixing?
Unidentified-driver claims come with an extra condition: Texas requires actual physical contact between the unknown vehicle and you or your property before uninsured motorist coverage pays, and the insurer carries the burden of proving a vehicle was not uninsured if that is disputed (§§ 1952.104, 1952.109). Our hit-and-run guide covers that physical-contact rule and the reporting steps in depth.
Property damage works a little differently from an injury claim. If you have both collision coverage and UM/UIM property damage coverage, you choose which one to use, and if neither limit alone covers the damage, you can use both together, with one deductible applying as the primary coverage and only the difference between the two deductibles applying to the second (§ 1952.107). Your insurer also keeps a right to pursue the at-fault driver after paying a UM/UIM claim, which differs from how personal injury protection works; see our PIP guide for that contrast.
Where do you bring a UM/UIM claim, and what should you track?
A lawsuit over UM/UIM coverage can be filed only in the county where you lived when the crash happened, or the county where the crash occurred, regardless of where your insurer might otherwise be sued (§ 1952.110). That venue rule is narrower than the general rules for suing an insurance company, so confirm it early if you have moved since the crash.
Keep the crash report, the at-fault driver’s insurance information or the lack of it, your own declarations page showing your UM/UIM limits, and records of any settlement you reach with the at-fault driver’s insurer before you finalize it. A UIM claim depends on proving both fault and the size of your damages, so the evidence behind your underlying injury claim is the same evidence that supports the UM/UIM claim. If a Houston-area crash left you dealing with an uninsured or underinsured driver, The Joseph Law Firm offers a free consultation to go through your policy and the timing questions above.
Common questions
What is the difference between uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage?
Uninsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver has no liability insurance at all, or when that driver's insurer cannot pay because it is insolvent. Underinsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver does have insurance, but the limits on that policy are lower than the UM/UIM limits in your own policy. Texas treats both as the same type of coverage, usually written together as UM/UIM, and insurers must offer both unless you reject them in writing. Which one applies in your case depends on what the other driver's policy actually carried, not just on the size of your damages.
Do I have to buy UM/UIM coverage in Texas?
No, but your insurer has to offer it. Texas law requires every auto liability policy sold in the state to include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage unless a named insured rejects it in writing, and that rejection can carry forward onto later policies with the same insurer. Many drivers reject it without realizing what they gave up, often to save a small amount on premium. Because so many Texas drivers carry only the state minimum liability limits, declining UM/UIM removes one of the more useful coverages available after a crash caused by someone else.
When does my insurer have to pay a UIM claim?
Generally, only after a judgment or an agreement with your insurer establishes that the other driver was at fault and that the vehicle was underinsured. The Texas Supreme Court has held that simply demanding payment or filing suit against your own insurer does not create a duty to pay; the obligation depends on proving the other driver's liability and the shortfall in their coverage, the way any other injury claim would. That rule surprises people who expect UM/UIM to work like a simple first-party payment. Build your case the same way you would against the at-fault driver.
Does UM/UIM cover a hit-and-run driver who was never found?
It can, but Texas adds a condition for an unidentified driver: there must have been actual physical contact between that driver's vehicle and you or your property. A driver who swerves you off the road without touching your car can leave you without a UM claim under that rule, even with witnesses. Our hit-and-run guide explains how to document contact and what to do if coverage is denied on that basis. If the driver is later identified, the analysis shifts back to a normal underinsured-motorist claim against a known person's policy.
Can I use my collision coverage and UM/UIM property damage coverage on the same claim?
Yes, if one alone is not enough. Texas lets you choose which coverage to use first, and if neither limit by itself covers the damage, you can apply both, with one deductible treated as primary and only the gap between the two deductibles charged against the second. You cannot recover more than your actual damages by combining them. This mostly matters for a newer or financed vehicle, where repair costs or a payoff balance can exceed what either single coverage limit would pay on its own.
Where do I file a lawsuit against my own insurer over a UM/UIM claim?
Only in the county where you lived at the time of the crash, or the county where the crash happened. That rule is narrower than where you might otherwise be allowed to sue an insurance company, so it matters if you have since moved. Before filing anything, gather the crash report, your policy's declarations page showing your UM/UIM limits, and whatever you know about the at-fault driver's coverage. An attorney can confirm venue and whether a judgment or a direct agreement with your insurer is the faster path to payment.
Sources (10)
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.101 (UM/UIM coverage required; rejection in writing)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.102 (uninsured motor vehicle)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.103 (underinsured motor vehicle)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.104 (required provisions; actual physical contact)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.105 (liability limits)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.107 (recovery under collision or combined coverage)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.109 (burden of proof in dispute)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.110 (venue)statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Brainard v. Trinity Universal Ins. Co., 216 S.W.3d 809 (Tex. 2006)storage.courtlistener.com
- Texas Department of Insurance: Auto insurance guidetdi.texas.gov
Prepared from public sources by the firm's editorial team. Pending review by attorney Jim A. Joseph. Last updated . This page is general information, not legal advice. Read our editorial policy
The information provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and is not to be considered legal advice for your case. Please contact our lawfirm for legal advice about your case.

